A few bookish opinions

If there is one thing that the A-team of Blogchatter loves doing – whether in the middle of the day or during the Wednesday Twitter chats and sometimes later in the evening – it is to share our deepest secrets around books, authors and writing.

Our WhatsApp group is a safe space where we talk about popular books we don’t like, dissect writing styles that we adore and recommend books to each other because after working together for so long, we just look at a book and go, “You know what, you are going to love this one.”

Today, I’ll attempt to share a few of my bookish opinions. Judge away!

#1: I dislike how Indian writers over explain our Indianness. I recently read a book that had almost 40% dialogues in Spanish and it did nothing to derail my experience of it. Please, it’s okay to own our desi-ness.

#2: I hate how we have started marketing books like, “This book is The Prestige meets The Song of Achilles.” First, this book is NOT a combination of those two amazing pieces of art. And second, you’re setting me up with false expectations. Find better blurb writers, please.

#3: I love the tags on ao3 and how they tell you exactly what to expect when you decide to pick up a fanfiction of 126,687 words. I think I would like similar tags from books: major character death (so I’m prepared to cry), slow burn (so I don’t get impatient) and this book is unhinged (so I know exactly what to expect).

A screenshot of the tags as they appear on ao3. See clarity. Slow burn, fluff, and all the good stuff!
See the clarity. Slow burn, fluff, and love confessions. Does a wonderful job of setting up expectations.

#4: Blurbs too have become so misleading; I have almost stopped reading them. Sometimes, I feel the blurb is talking about a book it wishes the author had written and not the one the author actually wrote. I only ever read the blurb if the title and cover of the book haven’t convinced me enough to add it to my TBR.

#5: I love the covers that are being designed these days. You can see the attention to detail and when some element from the cover starts making sense as you read the book, it’s even better!

Cover photo of the book Middlegame by Seanan McGuire. This is still the best cover I have seen in ages and I remember when I reached the part that dealt with this cover.
This is still one of my fav covers and it was exhilarating when the cover started to make sense.

#6: I have read some questionable stuff, including books around A/B/O universe, magic being used for weird shenanigans, a monster that has a pet fish and a sports mafia romance. In two books, there was a romantic sub-plot between a character and a spaceship. I absolutely love how manic my recommendations look on Goodreads.

#7: I do not trust people who say they haven’t read a book, especially a fiction book, in their life.

#8: I do not understand Booker or Pulitzer Prize winning books. 95% of them are pretentious. However, if a book has been nominated for a Hugo, a Nebula or an Orange Prize, I know they’ll be worth my time.


This post is a part of Blogchatter Half Marathon 2023 

8 responses to “A few bookish opinions”

  1. Our opinions match! In the MM romance genre, a lot of authors use exactly these types of tags. Even on manga listings and those who primarily read fanfictions and other non-traditional, online writings are very familiar with them. They really narrow the niche we’re looking for. And I totally agree with owning our desiness. I don’t know why we do this. I actually have an impulse to clarify Indian things even on my blog and it kills me. I’ve become aware of it and am nipping it these days! Love this post~

    Liked by 1 person

    1. Yes authors who publish primarily on KU have started following the fanfic route. I think its genius! And I hear you on wanting to explain desi-isms and I’m so glad you’re trying to stop.

      Liked by 1 person

  2. Enjoyed reading this post! Point 2 ―people often do that these days, and I wonder why. Or sometimes, blurbs are like detailed synopsis of the story. I begin to lose interest if the blurb is too long.

    And that’s a striking and intriguing cover!

    Liked by 1 person

    1. You bring up an interesting point: length of blurb. I agree sometimes it feels like they have told me the entire story just in the blurb. I feel like that about movie trailers too.

      Like

  3. With you on this.
    But not all Bookers are pretentious. Hilary Mantel is superb, for example.

    Liked by 1 person

    1. Hmmm maybe I should give Wolf Hall a try then.

      Like

  4. Great post, as always, Suchita. And the pic you have used for this blog post is arresting!

    Liked by 1 person

    1. Thank you so much Aishwariya!

      Liked by 1 person

Leave a reply to Suchita Cancel reply